David Cameron launched his European renegotiation this week with a speech at Chatham House and a letter to Donald Tusk, president of the European Council, setting out his demands (see below). His plan is “far more modest” than the “new settlement” he “rashly” promised two years ago, says the FT.
Yet this has been a tough balancing act ever since the PM gambled on calling a referendum on Britain’s EU membership in 2013. Asking too much risks rejection by Europe; too little is “guaranteed to stir the blood of Europhobe hardliners”. His approach has already been attacked by Eurosceptic Tory MP Jacob Rees-Mogg, who called it “pretty thin gruel”.
No wonder, says Leo McKinstry in the Daily Express – it is “pathetically unambitious”. Wanting the EU to become “more competitive” is a “statement of the blindingly obvious”. The exemption from ever-closer union is “a meaningless rhetorical trick to disguise the continuing destruction of our sovereignty”.
As for barring migrants from claiming benefits in their first four years (43% of EU newcomers are on welfare), it is unlikely the British courts, “fixated by… on the four-year rule, the European Commission’s view that this would be “highly problematic” has Cameron now saying that he is “open to different ways of dealing with it”. We shouldn’t be surprised, says Rachel Sylvester in The Times. The renegotiation is a “political device designed to hold his party together”, not a genuine effort to change our relationship with the continent.
Yet even although Cameron “has set the bar very low, he is still going to trip over it”, says Peter Oborne in the Daily Mail. The EU “will be very reluctant to meet” even these mild demands. If they snub him, he will either have to lead “the ‘Out’ campaign” or stick with ‘In’ and swallow the “rightful” ridicule of his opponents. Either way, “the potential for chaos and shambles is huge”.
The four key demands
• Cut the number of EU migrants by reducing access to benefits
• Greater trade protections for non-euro members
• A British opt-out from the EU’s aim to forge “ever-closer union”
• A commitment to cut red tape and boost competitiveness within the EU