Just over a year ago the first new bank to hit Britain’s high streets in almost 140 years opened. Metro Bank’s first branch in Holborn, London, promised to change the way we bank in Britain. There would be longer opening hours, attentive, helpful staff and free giveaways when you opened a bank account. So, a year on, has Metro Bank been a success and what impact has it had on the rest of the banking market?
In short, it seems to be doing rather well. It is expanding its branch network faster than forecast, with six branches already open in London and at least 200 set to be open in the capital by 2020. The bank is also, reportedly, proving popular with customers, with founder Vernon Hill saying deposits are “growing rapidly” – although there are no official figures to support that claim yet.
Anyone who has suffered years of poor service with their current bank will quickly realise the attraction of Metro Bank. Its branches are open seven days a week with longer hours of 8am to 8pm on weekdays so you don’t have to dash in and queue up in your lunch hour. So far the bank is also meeting its target of being able to open accounts and hand over a cash card within 15 minutes. There are some fairly eye-catching incentives too. Last weekend, if you’d taken your dog into a branch and opened an account, you’d have received £20. But there’s more to Metro than gimmicks – it’s received glowing reviews on various industry websites.
However, if you value returns over service, you’ll probably not be tempted by Metro Bank as its accounts do not compete with the big banks when it comes to interest rates. Metro Bank’s current account doesn’t pay any interest and its savings account rates aren’t competitive either. The bank also isn’t the best option for anyone outside London – there will be no branches outside the capital for some time yet. If you are going for internet banking, FirstDirect comes up tops in customer satisfaction surveys and offers better rates.
Nonetheless, for those Londoners who are willing to give up current-account interest in return for customer service, Metro Bank is an attractive option. There is no fee for the current account, the overdraft charges are straight-forward and competitive and you’ll be treated properly. The competition certainly seems to be worried. Earlier this month Barclays bank announced it was going to focus on delivering a better customer service. Royal Bank of Scotland launched a customer charter last year, which included having branches open longer and being quicker to replace ATM cards. Even Santander (branded worst bank for customer service by Which?) is employing 1,000 more staff in its call centres. For that alone, Metro Bank deserves its plaudits.
Current accounts compared
| Bank | Which? score | Account | Credit interest rate | Overdraft rate |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Metro | N/A | Personal current account | 0% | 15% EAR |
| First Direct | 90% | 1st Account | 0% | 0% for the first £250, then 15.9% EAR |
| Smile (Co-op) | 86% | Current account | 0.12% AER | 15.9% EAR |
| Nationwide BS | 69% | Flex Account | 0% | 18.9% EAR |
| HSBC | 57% | Bank Account | 0% | 19.9% EAR |
| Lloyds TSB | 55% | Classic Account with Vantage | 0% or 2% AER if you pay in £1,000 a month, rising to 4% AER if you pay in £5,000-£8,000 a month* | 19.3% EAR |
| NatWest/RBS | 54% | Current account | 0% | 0% for the first £100, then 19.89% EAR |
| Barclays | 51% | Bank account | 0% | 19.3% EAR |
| Halifax | 50% | Reward current account | 0% unless you pay in £1,000 a month, in which case you’ll receive £5 a month up to £2,500 | £1 a day on overdrafts |
| Santander | 42% | Preferred current account | 5% for the first 12 months on balances up to £2,500, then 1% | 0% for the first 12 months, then 50p a day capped at £5 a month |
*if you dip into overdraft you won’t receive any credit interest