Here at MoneyWeek, we’re big fans of gold. We’re also pretty keen on tungsten.
However, we’re not so enthused about the idea of mixing the two. While both metals share the same density, tungsten costs a fraction of the price. That gives a very strong incentive to try to pass one off as the other – and Felix Salmon of Reuters has recently been reporting on claims that some gold bars have been ‘salted’ with tungsten rods.
Details remain sketchy – and it is almost certain that the problem is limited to a few rogue bars. The myth of billions of doctored bullion in bank vaults remains just that – a myth.
However, this is a reminder that fakes do exist. Only four years ago the Central Bank of Ethiopia had to re-check all its gold after being scammed into buying plated steel.
The good news is that a few steps will eliminate virtually all of the risk from physical gold.
Buy from a reputable dealer
The first thing you should do is to buy from a reputable dealer. These will have enough expertise to spot fakes before they get into circulation.
As well as fakes and poor value, buying from a hole-in-the-wall operator also runs the risk that the gold has been stolen. This is a serious problem in some parts of the UK.
At the very least you should ask how long they have been in business and what measures they take to stop bogus coins. Firms that have existed for a long time will have a reputation to protect.
Buy well-known coins
If you’re buying gold coins, you should stick to series that are well known. Not only are fakes easier to spot, you will be paying for the gold in the coin, not the design (the ‘numismatic’ value).
The krugerrand, Britannia and sovereign are good places to start. The first is the most common coin in the world while the Britannia and sovereign are legal tender in the UK, and so are free from capital gains tax.
Some basic ‘fake’ tests
The most detailed tests can be very expensive – and should not be necessary if you’ve followed the advice above. However, there are some very basic steps that you can follow.
The most basic test is to use a magnet. Since gold (like silver) is not magnetic, anything that sticks to a magnet is dodgy. Gold is also an inert metal (ie, it doesn’t rust), so a black or greenish hue is a sign that it is metal plated with gold.
Any coins or bars should feel relatively dense. You can try to judge this yourself, or buy a cheap scale and calipers to check the density. There are also specialised scales that are designed specifically for sovereigns and can be bought on eBay for less than £50.
As with any investment, the most important test is the ‘smell test’ – if you think that something doesn’t look right, go somewhere else.
Alternatives to physical gold
Of course, if you don’t want the hassle, you can avoid buying your own physical gold entirely. There are plenty of low-cost gold exchange trade funds (ETFs) and exchange traded commodities (ETCs).
Clearly, the disadvantage with ETFs is that you don’t have the physical gold itself in your hands. However, as a cheap, convenient way to get exposure to the gold price, they are hard to beat.
We like the iShares Physical Gold ETC (LN:SGLN), which simply holds physical bullion. With a total expenses ratio of 0.25%, it is a low-cost way to track the gold price. ETFS Physical Swiss Gold (LN:SGBS) is held in a Swiss bank vault, and the fees are only slightly higher at 0.39%. (You can also get sterling-denominated versions of gold ETFs).
Another option is to bet on the price of gold. This is one of the key betting markets, so spreads are generally low across the board.
However, as with any spread bet, this is a leveraged investment. You could end up losing more that your initial stake – so it is not for everyone, and it is most definitely not the same as holding physical gold.
For anyone concerned about a potential repeat of the WorldSpreads situation, just remember to limit the amount of money you hold with any one broker. As my colleague Phil Oakley has pointed out, the Financial Services Compensation Scheme (FSCS) offers up to £50,000 worth of cover in the event that your firm goes out of business (assuming it is Financial Services Authority-authorised).